In the warm weather it is very hard. Both symbolize strong personalities but they are not rigid. She is witty and clever, and can be very fierce.
She struggles while watching Sophie grow up in this culture and wishes to discipline her the way a proper Chinese girl is raised. Otherwise daughter complain mother is not supportive.
Here it is the other way around. Both are old and their main conflict is with their children daughter or granddaughter.
Her sole concern is not the joblessness but the differences in the socio-cultural backgrounds. This makes their personalities alike but different from the younger generations.
There are indications that John would like to send his mother-in-law back to China. Says the daughter, "I have a young daughter and a depressed husband and no one to turn to. Grandmother must move out. The mother is none too happy to have to face the day-in-day-out responsibility for the child.
These stories both deal with relationships between mothers and daughters, even though they are very different. The main difference between both protagonists is their final adaptability to the situation. These stories just happen to show extreme cases of this, where the relationships are ended.
Beside this similarity, there are certain other resemblances in their character as well disposition. The mother must move out.
Both protagonists are similar as they look at the new socio-cultural realties from their pre-conceived socio-cultural notions and experiences. Johnson admires heritage for its practical utility and personal importance.To be honest, I really think the title of this short story to be very accurate.
“Who’s Irish?” Even though the main character’s son-in-law and his family is Irish, the story mostly talks about the elderly main character (who is a chinese immigrant) and her grand-daughter’s mischievous ways. The story “Who’s Irish” by Gish Jen is a story of an elderly Chinese woman, living in America, trying to help her daughter and her family raise her granddaughter Sophie.
She struggles while watching Sophie grow up in this culture and wishes to discipline her the way a proper Chinese girl is. Gish Jen, born Lillian Jen (Chinese: 任 璧 蓮) August 12,is a contemporary American writer and speaker.
Summary And Characterization Summary The story “Who’s Irish” by Gish Jen is a short story about an elderly Chinese grandmother living with her daughters family in America, trying to help raise their child Sophia. She struggles watching Sophie grow up in a culture so distant from the way she raised her daughter, and even further from how she was.
The New Yorker, September 14, P. The narrator, a sixty-eight-year-old Chinese immigrant, struggles with her truculent half-Irish granddaughter, and is asked to move out of the house by. Summary of Gish Jen's Who's Irish Essay Words 3 Pages Gish Jen’s “Who’s Irish” tells the story of a sixty-eight-year-old Chinese immigrant and her struggle to accept other cultures different from her own.Download